Should I trade my 2005 A4 for a 2005 audi S4?? What do y'all think??? Help help!

My car only has 36,532 miles and the S4 has 61,123 but they are selling it at a good price. Let me know fellas what you think.

 

I would, depending on the condition between the two cars.

 

Well my AUDI A4 is CPO by the Audi Dealership the other one is also CPO. So this is why it's a tough choice to make.

 

do it man

 

I pondered the same thing.
My opinion: If you don't mod, then yes. If you can mod, then no.
Gas milage will kill you on the S4. They are pigs on gas.
The A4 can be made faster than the S4.
The only thing I'd kill for from an S4 is the seats. Other than that, they do look nice in my rear view mirror.

 

Also look up what the insurance difference is on both vehicles. I couldn't agree more w/ what bustanut said, if you don't plan on modding either then get the S4. That V8 is so smooth and reliable. But if you'd ever want a BT upgrade then keep the A4. Is yours USP? I think the USP's look better than S4's IMO. Its just those damn Recaro seats that hug you. I might sell unnecessary things like the radio, rear brakes, dashboard and windshield to get my hands on S4 seats!