Replace All Four Tires?
 

I have a 2006 AWD 2.0T A4 which picked up a nail this past weekend. This morning, the dealer says that I need to replace all 4 tires. I'm thinking about putting the new tires on the front only. I understand that Audi recommends replacing all four, but that doesn't make much sense. Anyone else have thoughts about this?

RE: Replace All Four Tires?
 

just repair the tyre, why on earth would they say change all the tyres[:-]

RE: Replace All Four Tires?
 

The nail that went into the tire made a very significant hole. The nail was quite large. It looked like a mini stake.

RE: Replace All Four Tires?
 

ask if it can be repaired by a tyre fitter ( not the dealer ) if not replace that wheel only, do you have a full size spare wheel? have them fit that and the other new tyre to the front and put the worn one as a spare that way you have 2 new tyres on the front;)

RE: Replace All Four Tires?
 

How worn are the tires? if there IS significant tread left you can replace the fronts. If the tires are pretty worn, you should replace all four. The reason is because worn tires have a different circumfrance than new tires, and on an all wheel drive it puts stress on the car due to wheels turningat different speeds all the time.

RE: Replace All Four Tires?
 

strange answer there but im not going into 4x4 cars nor am I even going to explain the above answer^^ but if the tyres are worn and they need change then change them if not then only change/repair the damaged one

RE: Replace All Four Tires?
 

bishops answer is right, same reason you shouldnt put a wider tire in the rear on an all wheel drive, due to the added weight and friction(due to larger contact patch)the tranny will wear faster and you will have problems with rotation and what not.

RE: Replace All Four Tires?
 

its not the added weight of friction that causes the tranny to wear, they can handle that, its the fact that alot of times when people stagger the wheels the get the over all rolling radius off becasue they either dont know or arent smart enough to get it right and have the radius be the same

RE: Replace All Four Tires?
 

of course now why didn't I think of that ( is that how the new cars are set up?? );)

RE: Replace All Four Tires?
 

lol dave your a silly mofo