B5 Models Please discuss all 1996 - 2001 B5 A4 topics here...

turbo upgrade help

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old Nov 18, 2010 | 08:43 AM
  #41  
vtraudt's Avatar
2nd Gear
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 1,104
From: Brighton, MI
Default

Originally Posted by slappy_dunbar
Are you able to cannibalize a turbine rotor from a K04? To use it you'd need to machine your turbo's turbine housing to fit it. Plus you'd need to balance the rotating assembly when you have the replacement turbine rotor on it. Seems like a lot of work.
Yes, I have access to K04 (or pretty much any other, certainly lots of KKK) wheels. Is the shaft diameter the same? How easy can the turbine wheel be remove/reinstalled from the shaft?

What is involved in replacing the current K03 setup with a K04 setup (exhaust, air, lube, cooling, mechanical connections)? If not much (ideally, TRUE one-on-one replacement without ANY mods), this would be a better way (possibly even modifying the wheels/housing for better characteristics, similar to what was done to the K03)?

If a lot: can a K04 exhaust housing be bolted to the K03 (again: manifold flange and test pipe connection fit)?
 
Old Nov 18, 2010 | 12:37 PM
  #42  
Andrew149's Avatar
3rd Gear
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 2,801
From: Raleigh NC
Default

just think as a ko4 as a ko3 same thing you dont haft to change anything but i would recommend retunning the car
 
Old Nov 19, 2010 | 08:30 AM
  #43  
slappy_dunbar's Avatar
1st Gear
Joined: Aug 2010
Posts: 14
Default

Originally Posted by vtraudt
Yes, I have access to K04 (or pretty much any other, certainly lots of KKK) wheels.
Can you get:
  • turbine housing from K04-015
  • Turbine rotor from K04-015 (or) K04-020
 
Old Mar 20, 2011 | 09:25 AM
  #44  
vtraudt's Avatar
2nd Gear
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 1,104
From: Brighton, MI
Default

Originally Posted by slappy_dunbar
Can you get:
  • turbine housing from K04-015
  • Turbine rotor from K04-015 (or) K04-020
Slappy, I use a K04-015 (since it is 'fully interchange' for installation on the 1.8T) as a base.
What is the difference (in characterisitic) between the 015 and 020 turbine rotor?

Still looking for injector and file.
 
Old Mar 24, 2011 | 09:19 AM
  #45  
vtraudt's Avatar
2nd Gear
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 1,104
From: Brighton, MI
Default

Originally Posted by slappy_dunbar
That boost curve makes sense given the restrictions of your K03 turbine rotor. The software has to pull back boost to protect against exhaust manifold backpressure and over-hot EGTs. What does VAG-COM show your MAF to be reading? 170-ish?
Slappy,
coming back to this older post.
Finally managed to a) get my hand on son's car and b) learned to log with VAGcom.

Naturally, I didn't get all the data I should have. But below is what I logged. Max. Boost was 16.5 psi (likely because it was 40 deg. Normally is 18.5 psi) at 4000 rpm (dropping to 10 psi at 7000 rpm).

Surprises:
a) MAF shows a max of 165 g/s. What is the practical limit for the MAF?
b) Injector timing seems to max out at 16.32 ms? But already at 2500 RPM???
c) N75 is starting to 'pull back' boost (?) at 2900 rpm. Because 'running out of fuel'?
d) not sure what to make of the ignition timing.

Obviously, the small K03 hot side (stock wheel, slight clip, only 'massaged' housing) is very limiting (will be fixed going to a K04 based setup).

Comments and interpretations, please!

With the larger hot side of a K04 based turbo, I also hope to fit a slightly larger compressor wheel into the K04 compressor side.
Not sure if it helps, but I am currently opening up a stock AEB exhaust manifold to improve flow/reduce back pressure (3" down pipe + Miltek, no cat already on; other: Carbonio intake, FMIC, APR F1; AFPR standing by).

Is 200 g/s with the stock MAF realistic?

Tune and injectors: everyone is still pointing at the GIAC PC16. But is 31 lb at 2.8 bar (good for 60 hp at best) sufficient?

Not sure what the last word is on the Unitronics file for the Frankenturbo (chart shows 222 g/s at 32 psi for the FH4, K04-15: 185 g/s); last I read was the 'crash and burn' posted by Unitronics somewhere. What is current status?

Since money for the tune is a big factor, going for a custom tune (and dyno) is not an option.

Name:  LogChart031311.jpg
Views: 248
Size:  98.7 KB
 
Old Mar 24, 2011 | 11:38 AM
  #46  
Mike-2ptzero's Avatar
4th Gear
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 3,274
From: Phoenix, Arizona area
Default

A. Stock max reading for the ndbw MAF is 189 g/s, higher if the tuner has changed the scale for the maf 0-5 volt signal.

B. On the ndbw cars the max injector reading is what your seeing, after that the ecu just dumps fuel.


Did you log block 022 which is the timing correction readings?


Why do you say the K03 is limited? I made 250chp with my stock K03 and was pushing up to 215 g/s with it. I have also seen the K04-15 on the 2000 GIAC J31 file hit 215 g/s pushing 25-28psi.
 
Old Mar 24, 2011 | 12:41 PM
  #47  
vtraudt's Avatar
2nd Gear
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 1,104
From: Brighton, MI
Default

Originally Posted by Mike-2ptzero
A. Stock max reading for the ndbw MAF is 189 g/s, higher if the tuner has changed the scale for the maf 0-5 volt signal.

==> Current chip/tune is the dreaded "T.A.P. +50 hp". I assume it is similar to other mild tunes not requiring much if any hardware changes. I assume not change to MAF scale.

B. On the ndbw cars the max injector reading is what your seeing, after that the ecu just dumps fuel.

==> that means my fuel is limiting the engine from 2500 rpm already.
Can the injector really do 16.32 ms all the way to read line? At 7000 rpm, the stroke duration is only 34 ms?

RPM R per sec Ignitions per sec Stroke duration ms
7000.00 116.67 29.17 34.29



Did you log block 022 which is the timing correction readings?

==> I only logged "Group 002, 003, 114". The timing I plotted was the 4th data column of Group 003.

Why do you say the K03 is limited? I made 250chp with my stock K03 and was pushing up to 215 g/s with it. I have also seen the K04-15 on the 2000 GIAC J31 file hit 215 g/s pushing 25-28psi.
==> My assumption (pointed out by forum posts) is that my current K03's limit is on the hot side (almost stock) while the cold side with the K04 wheel is probably not (boost drops from 18.5 at 4000 to 10 at 7000).
But with the data, I know suspect that running out of fuel so early, and at the same time wastegate duty cycle jumping up, that the ECU is cutting in (to prevent lean condition), probably long before the turbo is at its limit?

I contacted Unitronics today what/if they offer for AEB K04, since I saw posts for 'stage 2+' (for example on Frankenturbos) files using 380cc (36 lb at 3 bar) and larger MAF. As opposed to GIAC PC16 using 31lb (325cc at 3 bar). I would like to get the tune and injectors and run it on the current setup (before the K04 based turbo is going in).
 
Old Mar 24, 2011 | 01:01 PM
  #48  
Mike-2ptzero's Avatar
4th Gear
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 3,274
From: Phoenix, Arizona area
Default

Timing readings on block 003 are the actual timing readings, you want to log block 022 to see how much timing the ecu is pulling in each cylinder.

How can the ECU cut boost because the car is running lean? It isn't like your ndbw ECu is even using the 02 sensor reading during WOT, it only uses it during Idle/PT. This is why it is so much harder for the tuners to make good tunes for the ndbw cars and why you see so many running either rich or lean at WOT. The narrow band ECU's dont have a target(spec) AFR to look at during WOT like the wide band cars.

The WG duty cycle is a set value based on throttle position, rpm and engine load. So if it is dropping it is because one of them is not what it should be.

As for injector on time, yes it can seeing that the ECU can leave them on as long as it wants. Hell I saw injector readings on my K03 setup that were well into the 30's.

BTW what does 7k have to do with a K03 or K04? Anyone running that size turbo to 7k is out of their mind seeing that both the K03/K04 are pretty much out of breath by 5500-6k rpm when pushing high boost. On my K03 setup I was shifting gears way before 6k.
 
Old Mar 24, 2011 | 03:25 PM
  #49  
vtraudt's Avatar
2nd Gear
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 1,104
From: Brighton, MI
Default

Originally Posted by Mike-2ptzero
Timing readings on block 003 are the actual timing readings, you want to log block 022 to see how much timing the ecu is pulling in each cylinder.
==> Thanks. Will look for that blog for the next logging session.

Originally Posted by Mike-2ptzero
How can the ECU cut boost because the car is running lean? It isn't like your ndbw ECu is even using the 02 sensor reading during WOT, it only uses it during Idle/PT.
==> Good to know. But the ECU effectively is cutting boost by controlling the N75. Just as you point out (above and below) not by using O2 sensor values.

==> If not based on O2 values, how is the ECU (if at all) preventing 'lean'? I would have expected lean codes (with stock injectors maxed out, MAF of 165 g/s and higher boost). Surprisingly: no codes.

Originally Posted by Mike-2ptzero
The WG duty cycle is a set value based on throttle position, rpm and engine load. So if it is dropping it is because one of them is not what it should be.
==> Need to look at the 3 values you mention then to understand why the N75 valve is opening the wastegate, with engine load being the only parameter influenced by the turbo setup. ECU must be seeing engine loads that are too high (for the throttle pos/rpm).

Originally Posted by Mike-2ptzero
As for injector on time, yes it can seeing that the ECU can leave them on as long as it wants. Hell I saw injector readings on my K03 setup that were well into the 30's.
==> Is maxing out (16.32 ms) an indicator for 'fuel limitation'?

Originally Posted by Mike-2ptzero
BTW what does 7k have to do with a K03 or K04? Anyone running that size turbo to 7k is out of their mind seeing that both the K03/K04 are pretty much out of breath by 5500-6k rpm when pushing high boost. On my K03 setup I was shifting gears way before 6k.
==> Mike: Logging, not driving/shifting. 2 different things!
 
Old Mar 24, 2011 | 05:38 PM
  #50  
Mike-2ptzero's Avatar
4th Gear
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 3,274
From: Phoenix, Arizona area
Default

Originally Posted by vtraudt

==> Good to know. But the ECU effectively is cutting boost by controlling the N75. Just as you point out (above and below) not by using O2 sensor values.

==> If not based on O2 values, how is the ECU (if at all) preventing 'lean'? I would have expected lean codes (with stock injectors maxed out, MAF of 165 g/s and higher boost). Surprisingly: no codes.
ECU does not throw lean/rich codes during WOT, only for too rich or too lean of a Fuel trim correction at idle and part throttle. So if the car is going lean/rich during WOT you will not get a code at all.




==> Is maxing out (16.32 ms) an indicator for 'fuel limitation'?
It could mean a few different things. The injectors are to small, MAF readings are causing the ecu to spray way too much fuel for the actual amount of air coming in or the tune is just all screwed up. Did you check block 032 readings with the key on and the engine off?

Mike: Logging, not driving/shifting. 2 different things!
Yes I understand that, but I pretty sure you are driving while your logging. lol
No point in logging something that is pretty much pointless doing just to drive the car. Well unless people like driving the car well outside its power band and where it is making way less power seeing that the power is taking a nose dive.
 



All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:39 PM.