...For example. Should I get a 2000 s4 with 65,000 for ~$15,000 or an '01.5 with 70,000 miles for ~$18,000? My other question (perhaps a better one) if there is a 2000 model with about 70,000 miles and an '02 w/ 70,000 miles is it worth the extra couple grand for the '02?

 

well id say the 01.5. the mileage is really irrelevant at only 5k difference. and being an 01.5 you have uprades made that took care of a lot of the problems had. Are either modded at all?

 

Neither says that it is modded, assuming everything is equal...would you pay the extra ~$3000 for one year newer car with the reliability changes?

 

yes, i prob would. youre almost 2 years newer.. and then on top of that you have those differences in the car.. Try running a kelly blue book on it and see what the price differences they are. What color are they and do either have the sport package.