Topic of much debate amidst my friends

THE B6 S4 or an E46 M3?

and why?

 

heres a comparision on video
http://www.yoyo.org/~andy/private/TopgearM3.wmv

 

S4 you can only have so much fun in an M3....


BMWs are like porcupines....

theres always a ***** inside

 

s4 better overall car... better interior, fit and finish...good performance, ride etc.
m3 better 'sports car' traditional rwd config, oversteer, more wow factor.


both great cars...I'm biased,,,I love my s4...I need to drive in the snow and I wanted 4 doors so no contest...s4!

 

Thank you so much for calling me a *****...

I love S4's and M3's. But I just feel the M3 is more fun. I'm not a huge fan of 4 doors but when i need to get one it'll be an Audi.
There's no reason to bash a car as lovely as the M. Especially after "Top Speed" tested both cars on the track and the lesser horsepower 2 door won.

 

Most of us here love a good car, and the M3 has allot of friends here...my second car is a 635....so don't take gtma4's comments with too much seriousness.

btw...is that ur g/f in the pic?

 

Jenny,

I hope you've also checked http://www.bimmerforums.com and http://www.m3forum.net both of these are full of post about this topic as well. Personally, as stated above, my decision was based mainly on 2 doors or 4. They are both very comparable cars in performance, and aesthetics. Personally I prefer the looks of the BMW but then again I'm bias. Don't get me wrong the S4 is a beautiful car with great handling.

Ask yourself these questions:
Does it snow where I live?
If so will this be a daily driver for me?
Do I like 4 doors better then 2?
And last but not least.
Do I want a car that will beat the S4 in top end?

I have to tell you, I just drove my M3 from Tampa, FL to the Jersey Shore and back last week. Wonderful ride, 150MPH is smooth as glass, and I would do it again in a heart beat.

 

She is beautiful isn't she...

 

S4

 

God!
You even got the joke wrong!

It's supposed to be...


What's the difference between a porcupine and a BMW?

A porcupine has the "******" on the outside.



Personally I'm an Audiot...I aspire to be a "*****" too!

I'd LOVE to have an E46 convertible!

By the way, she's very pretty, and the car too.