No joke being thats a good problem to have...

The M Coupe is certainly sporty and cheaper, the convertibles are popular here in Hawaii. Fair weather Car, lacks practicality for sure

Porsche would be a huge statement on the road, quite the opposite of the understated beauty of Audi A4/S4s....

Man it really all depends on your personality and performance wants...

The M or the Cayman are honest to goodness Sports cars and chick magnets, while Audis are more sports performance persay...Girls who appreciate the Audi look are usually a little more brainy which can be a plus in the long run

eh...I'd say that if you want a true sports car, you have to go with the M or Porsche.

 

I agree with all that's been said. Take a test drive, although they are completely different cars, they deliver a similar experience, it's just which type of experience you prefer. Personally I would say the S4 just because of practicality.