go quattro or go home. nuff said.

 

I would take the 2005 for 18,800 with timing belt change.
If they don't accept that just tell them good luck trying to sell it this winter.

I would take the 2001 for 15,900 but make sure its all good otherwise.

Winter is a great time to buy these as they are hard to sell in January but go off the lots pretty easily in the spring. I got mine in January.

Also check features on both you may want or not want.
Manual or auto top, heated seats, homelink, NAV, check funtion of top, Multi-CD, Xenon